Skip to content

Stealth Agents payroll virtual assistants

See VAs
Payroll Firms

Payroll firms in Buffalo, NY

13 payroll companies in Buffalo, New York. Compare services, ratings, phone numbers and websites.

Firms
13
With site
11
Avg rating
4.8
Sponsored by Stealth Agents

Running the business AND the payroll back office?

A dedicated payroll VA can take timesheet collection, payroll run prep, and deduction reconciliation off your plate, so your team can focus on clients and growth.

  • Timesheet collection
  • Payroll run preparation
  • Deductions & benefits
  • Multi-state compliance support
Hire a payroll VA48-hour placement · USA timezone · No long-term contracts
Stealth Agents payroll virtual assistant at workAd

Payroll services in Buffalo, NY

Buffalo has 13 payroll companies listed in this directory, with 11 publishing a website and 12 carrying a public rating. The average rating among rated firms is 4.8. Liberty Tax has the highest public review volume in the city, with 103 reviews.

The most common specialty here is cpa & tax payroll. Employers should compare firms that support their workforce size and compliance profile instead of choosing the first listing. Use the filters below to narrow by specialty and website availability, then open two or three firm pages to compare editorial reviews and fee questions.

Updated 2026. Listing data comes from public business profiles and may change; confirm fees, tax filing guarantees, and availability directly with each firm.

Liberty Tax

Buffalo, NY 14215

★ 4.7
103
+1 716-328-1193

www.libertytax.com/10683

3120 Bailey Ave, Buffalo, NY 14215

CPA & Tax PayrollTax preparationDetails →

N&Y TAX

Buffalo, NY 14207

★ 5.0
12
+1 716-430-1156

www.nytax.us.com

563 Tonawanda St, Buffalo, NY 14207

CPA & Tax PayrollTax preparationDetails →

Advance Tax Services

Buffalo, NY 14202

★ 5.0
12
+1 716-563-8601

www.hpadvancetaxservice.com

50 Fountain Plz 14th Floor Suite 1400, Buffalo, NY 14202

CPA & Tax PayrollTax preparation serviceDetails →

Common questions about Buffalo payroll firms

How many payroll companies are in Buffalo?+

This directory lists 13 payroll service companies in Buffalo, New York. 11 of them publish a website, and 12 have a public rating. Coverage includes full-service payroll, CPA & tax payroll, bookkeeping, and HR/PEO specialists where available locally.

How much do payroll providers charge in Buffalo?+

Most payroll providers in the US charge a monthly base fee ($40–$150) plus $4–$15 per active W-2 employee or 1099 contractor. Buffalo pricing varies by pay frequency, headcount, and multi-state tax scope. Ask each firm for a written fee schedule including year-end W-2/1099 preparation and off-cycle run fees.

How do I choose a payroll service in Buffalo?+

Shortlist three firms that match your business structure, then ask the same questions about per-run fees, tax filing liability, input cutoff windows, accounting software integrations, and contract termination terms.

Payroll firms in nearby New York cities