Overview
Optima Benefits & Payroll operates from 1465 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618 in Rochester, New York, serving businesses across Rochester and nearby New York, Brooklyn, and Bronx. In the public business registry, the company is classified under payroll service with a primary directory assignment in Full-Service Payroll. According to its public profile summary, the practice highlights: "For the best customer service in handling your Benefit and Payroll needs. At Optima Benefits & Payroll, we care about helping your business. We are dedicated to our clients and provide resources and expertise in a timely…" Rochester currently has 30 listed payroll and accounting service providers, including 20 focused on full-service payroll, 7 focused on cpa & tax payroll, 2 focused on hr & peo solutions, placing Optima Benefits & Payroll in an active local market for employer compliance and payroll administration.
Services and specialties
Under its Full-Service Payroll classification, Optima Benefits & Payroll is positioned to support the recurring payroll and financial workflows that small and mid-sized employers require. Its public business profile specifically itemizes offerings such as Dental insurance, ACA Reporting (Groups over 50), Add-Ons, Benefit Administration, Billing Services, Business Insurances Accounting and Bill Pay. Standard published operating hours include Monday–Friday 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM, though employers should confirm cutoff times for payroll submission and off-cycle check runs.
What the public rating suggests
Optima Benefits & Payroll holds a 4.8 out of 5 public rating based on 141 reviews. For a payroll and business services provider in Rochester, a sample of 141 reviews represents a substantial public track record. A sustained 4.8 average across dozens of clients points to consistent execution on deadlines, tax filings, and client communication. Public reviewers frequently mention themes around quick response time, payroll specialists, responsive staff, clear explanations, employee benefits. Prospective clients should read recent feedback for specifics on tax notice resolution, responsiveness during payroll cutoff windows, and billing transparency.
Who it may suit
This firm is worth considering for employers in Rochester and nearby New York, Brooklyn, and Bronx seeking full-service payroll from an established New York office. As a dedicated payroll service provider, it suits organizations looking for reliable pay-cycle execution, multi-state tax withholding, and employee self-service portals. Companies with multi-state remote workers, tipped employees, or certified job-costing requirements should confirm specialized platform support during an initial consultation.
Questions to ask before hiring
Before signing a payroll service agreement with Optima Benefits & Payroll, ask how the fee schedule is structured: specifically whether pricing is a base per-run fee plus a per-employee charge, or a bundled monthly retainer. Confirm whether federal, New York, and local municipal tax deposits and quarterly filings are automated, and ask who bears responsibility if a filing deadline or tax notice issue arises. Clarify the payroll input cutoff window (for example, 48 hours vs. 24 hours before pay day), whether year-end W-2 and 1099 preparation carries an extra fee, and how the team handles garnishments, new-hire state reporting, and general ledger exports into QuickBooks, Xero, or your ERP.
How it compares locally
Across the 30 payroll firms listed in Rochester, the average public rating is 3.9 out of 5, compared with 4.8 for Optima Benefits & Payroll. Statewide across New York's 748 listed payroll providers, the average rating stands at 4.6. By review volume, Optima Benefits & Payroll ranks #2 in Rochester with 141 public reviews. Comparing two or three local providers in Rochester side by side helps clarify differences in software platforms, dedicated account representation, and total annual cost.
Verdict
Optima Benefits & Payroll is a verified full-service payroll option in Rochester, New York backed by a 4.8 out of 5 public rating from 141 reviews. Employers in Rochester or neighboring New York, Brooklyn, and Bronx comparing payroll partners should include it on their shortlist and verify per-run fees, tax compliance guarantees, and platform integrations directly.
About this review. This is an editorial summary based on public business listing data. It is not a customer review, a rating of service quality, or an endorsement. Fees, tax filing scope, and terms change; confirm them directly with the firm before signing anything.
